Maddy

Krista Allen

Cop

Michael Bellomo

Dom

Jon Bernthal

Church Organist

Aldo Bruschi

Keyboardist

Joey Carbone

Raphael

Guillermo Diaz

Connie

Kim Director

Donna

Daisy Eagan

Father Mark

Dean Edwards

Nunzio

John Fiore

Uncle Lui

Clement Fowler

Mrs. Nunzio

Joanne Genell

Michael

Adrian Grenier

Gladiator

Jeff Hephner

Blonde

Haley Michelle Joel

Donny Dulce

Donnie Keshawarz

Tina

Mila Kunis

Josie

Priscilla Lopez

Smiley

Gino Lucci

Limo Driver

Richard Mammary

Ralph

Lou Martini

Tony

Joey McIntyre

Customer

Ron Messer

Patty

Lisa Miller

Altar Boy

Vanessa Paradis

Celeste

Miari Peterson

Vinnie Black

Richard Portnow

Church Singer

Karen Ramey

Mickey

Nick Raynes

Joey

Richard Robichaux

Barry

Matthew Saldivar

Vicky

Laura Jean Salerno

Grandma Nunzio

Letty Serra

Johnny

Sebastian Stan

Bartender

Michael Straka

Sister Clare

Mary Testa

Zeppo

Tony Travis

Sal

Lenny Venito